A reference on the redlining of Los Angeles — the federal maps and deed covenants that sorted the city by race, and the music, schools, kitchens, parks and freeways that grew up inside those lines. Written from public record. Open for your memories.
1939
HOLC grades Los Angeles
A–D
“Best” to “hazardous”
1948
Covenants unenforceable
1968
Fair Housing Act
In 1939 federal appraisers for the Home Owners’ Loan Corporation colored Los Angeles in four grades. Red meant loans dried up. The map below starts from that sheet and follows it forward — into jazz clubs, high schools, taquerías, plazas and parks. Tap anything. Pin what it missed.
Click the map where the place is, then fill in the form below.
| Neighborhood | 1939 | In the appraiser’s words | What grew there | Today |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Central Avenue / South L.A. | D | “Subversive racial elements” — the sheets’ recurring phrase for non-white and immigrant residents | Dunbar Hotel, Club Alabam, Watts Prophets, G-funk | Majority Black & Latino |
| Boyle Heights | D | “Literally honeycombed with diverse and subversive racial elements” — Jewish, Japanese, Mexican, Russian, Black | Mariachi Plaza, Breed Street Shul, The Vex, Roosevelt High | ~95% Latino |
| East Los Angeles | D | Unincorporated; graded down for “Mexican” population and industry | Thee Midniters, Los Lobos, Whittier Blvd lowriders, the 1968 Blowouts | ~96% Latino |
| Watts | D | Rated hazardous; one of few areas where Black families could buy | Watts Towers, Jordan High, Ted Watkins Park, 1965 | Latino & Black |
| Wilmington | D | Redlined and zoned for refineries and the port | Port-life festivals; environmental-justice organizing | ~90% Latino |
| Westside — Beverly Hills, Palisades, Hancock Park | A | “Best” — covenants written into every deed | Canter’s (1948), Pan Pacific Park; Nat King Cole’s contested move, 1948 | Majority white |
Before the federal government drew a single red line, the real-estate profession had made exclusion a duty of membership. The HOLC borrowed its categories from the people who sold houses.
“A Realtor should never be instrumental in introducing into a neighborhood a character of property or occupancy, members of any race or nationality, or any individuals whose presence will clearly be detrimental to property values in that neighborhood.”
Article 34 stayed in the Code for a quarter century. Local boards taught it and expelled members who broke it. The FHA’s 1936 underwriting manual and the HOLC appraisers of 1939 did not invent “inharmonious racial groups”; they lifted the phrase and the practice from the boards. In 1950, two years after Shelley v. Kraemer, the explicit reference to race was removed — but the duty to protect “property values” remained, and boards read it as before.
Here is a clause as recorded on a lot — one of 167 in a Los Angeles Investment Company tract — and quoted by the California Supreme Court when the company sued over its occupancy by Alfred Gary and his wife: “It is hereby covenanted and agreed… that the said property shall not be sold, leased or rented to any persons other than of the Caucasian race, nor shall any person or persons other than of Caucasian race be permitted to occupy said lot or lots.” The court held the restriction on sale invalid but the condition on occupancy valid: a breach would cause the property to revert to the grantor, so the Garys could lose the house by living in it. The covenant ran until January 1, 1930. Los Angeles Investment Co. v. Gary, 181 Cal. 680 (1919). Assembly Bill 1466 (2021) directs recorders to find and redact such clauses; the originals remain for historians.
When the Rumford Fair Housing Act passed in September 1963, the California Real Estate Association — the state body of the same trade — sponsored and bankrolled Proposition 14 to repeal it and write a right to refuse into the state constitution. It carried in November 1964 with roughly sixty-five percent of the vote. The California Supreme Court struck it down in 1966; the U.S. Supreme Court affirmed in Reitman v. Mulkey (1967). Watts burned between the vote and the ruling. PBS SoCal · CRM Archive
In November 2020 the National Association of REALTORS® formally apologized for Article 34 and for the trade’s role in segregation, and adopted a fair-housing action plan. The apology is public; so is the century between. This archive treats both as part of the record — and asks what a rulebook enforced today still carries from the one written then.
A hill of mansions west of downtown where, in the 1940s, the Black elite of Los Angeles bought the houses covenants said they could not live in — and won, in court, about two and a half years before the Supreme Court agreed. Then the state routed a freeway through it.
1900s
West Adams Heights was laid out as one of the city’s grand addresses, its tract declarations restricting occupancy to whites. By 1939 the HOLC sheet marks the surrounding blocks red anyway: “infiltration” had begun.
1938–44
Hattie McDaniel, Louise Beavers, Ethel Waters and business leaders such as Norman O. Houston of Golden State Mutual buy on Harvard Boulevard and Hobart. The name comes from Harlem’s. Salons, Sunday parties, the address Black Los Angeles points to when it is told where it may not live.
1945
White neighbors ask the Superior Court to enforce the covenants and evict. Loren Miller, for the homeowners, argues the Fourteenth Amendment. In December Judge Thurmond Clarke refuses to enforce: “It is time that members of the Negro race are accorded, without reservations or evasions, the full rights guaranteed them under the 14th Amendment.” PBS SoCal
1948
Miller argues the companion case alongside Thurgood Marshall, and the Court makes Clarke’s ruling the law of the land. Sugar Hill becomes the model: Leimert Park and the Crenshaw district open to Black buyers over the following decade.
1961–65
The state routes Interstate 10 through West Adams. Homes on the hill are condemned and cleared; the neighborhood the covenants failed to keep white is cut in two by the alignment. The freeway opens in 1965 — the year of Watts. What the deed could no longer do, the right-of-way did.
Today
Mansions survive on both sides of the 10; the sound wall marks where the rest were. Only the blocks north of the freeway fall inside the Harvard Heights HPOZ — the southern remnant has no historic-district protection at all. The blocks are majority Black and Latino, and among the city’s most active preservation and anti-displacement neighborhoods. See it on the map ↑
Court rulings, federal programs, ballot measures and uprisings — set beside the songs, schools and storefronts they produced. Gold marks the moments a door opened.
1917
The Supreme Court strikes down racial zoning ordinances. Cities turn to the private substitute: the deed covenant. Opinion
1919
California’s Supreme Court rules a covenant may not bar a sale to a Black buyer — but a condition barring occupancy is valid, and breaking it can send the property back to the grantor. Alfred Gary and his wife hold the deed to one of 167 lots in the tract while risking the house if they live in it. Occupancy restrictions spread across every new L.A. tract. The clause, quoted
1924
The National Association of Real Estate Boards makes it an ethical duty never to introduce “members of any race or nationality” whose presence would hurt property values. The trade’s rule becomes the appraisers’ template. The industry chapter
1926
The Supreme Court lets private covenants stand. Watts is annexed to the city the same year.
1928
It opens as the Hotel Somerville, built for the first West Coast NAACP convention because downtown hotels would not take Black guests, and is renamed the Dunbar a few years later. Central Avenue becomes the jazz street of the West. Music
1933–34
The Home Owners’ Loan Corporation refinances Depression mortgages; the Federal Housing Administration’s underwriting manual favors homogeneous, covenanted tracts and warns against “inharmonious racial groups.”
1939
Appraisers grade the county A to D. Boyle Heights, Watts, Central Avenue, East L.A. and Wilmington are colored red; Beverly Hills, the Palisades and Hancock Park green. The sheets record “infiltration” by race and nationality. Mapping Inequality
1942
Japanese Americans are removed from Boyle Heights and Little Tokyo. Black wartime migrants, barred from covenanted areas, fill the emptied blocks — “Bronzeville.”
1945
NAACP attorney Loren Miller defends Black homeowners in West Adams — Hattie McDaniel among them — after neighbors sue to enforce covenants. Judge Thurmond Clarke throws the case out. Sugar Hill
1948
Courts may no longer enforce racial covenants. Nat King Cole buys in Hancock Park and finds a burned word on his lawn. Canter’s leaves Brooklyn Avenue for Fairfax; Jewish Boyle Heights begins moving west. LAPL
1959
California bars discrimination by businesses, including real-estate firms — the first crack in the private market.
1961–65
The Santa Monica Freeway is routed through West Adams, clearing the hill where the covenants had been beaten in 1945. The second redlining begins in concrete.
1963
Signed by Gov. Pat Brown in September. The California Real Estate Association immediately organizes to repeal it. Civil Rights Movement Archive
1964
Voters repeal Rumford by a two-to-one margin, writing a right to discriminate into the state constitution. Thee Midniters release “Whittier Blvd.” the following year. Music
1965
Six days of uprising in the redlined south. The McCone Commission names housing, schools and policing; the Watts Writers Workshop (1965), the Watts Summer Festival (1966) and the Watts Prophets follow.
1967
The U.S. Supreme Court voids Proposition 14. Rumford stands.
1968
In March, thousands of Chicano students walk out of Roosevelt, Garfield, Lincoln, Wilson and Belmont over conditions the grades had produced. In April, Congress outlaws redlining in lending. Schools
1977
Banks must meet the credit needs of the communities where they operate, including low- and moderate-income neighborhoods. LA Almanac
1980
Hollywood clubs won’t book East L.A. bands, so Boyle Heights builds its own room: Los Illegals, The Brat, The Plugz. Music
1988
N.W.A puts a C/D-graded city on every map that matters. G-funk, DJ Quik and — in 2012 — Kendrick Lamar’s “good kid, m.A.A.d city” follow the same streets. Music
1992
The uprising after the Rodney King verdict burns along the same redlined corridors as 1965.
1993
Interstate 105 opens after two decades of condemnation. Along the corridor — Watts, Willowbrook, Lynwood, Downey, Norwalk, Hawthorne — the court recorded an estimated 9,000 families, or 21,000 people, displaced, with 3,900 single-family and 3,000 multi-family dwellings to be acquired, figures entered into the federal record when residents sued and won. Keith v. Volpe, 352 F. Supp. 1324 (C.D. Cal. 1972)
2016
The University of Richmond and partners put every 1939 area description online. This archive builds on it.
2020
Ninety-six years after Article 34, the National Association of REALTORS® formally apologizes for its role in housing discrimination. The industry chapter
2021
California directs county recorders to find and redact racial covenants still sitting in property records.
2022
Census maps of where Black, Latino and white Angelenos live still trace the 1939 grades. The federal PAVE task force reports that homes in Black and Latino neighborhoods are still appraised below comparable homes elsewhere. Legacy
Redlining ended in law in 1968. It did not end in the ground. Lay the 2020 Census over the 1939 sheet and the same shapes appear — in wealth, in school budgets, in tree cover and in who gets stopped.
Thirty years of FHA-backed loans went overwhelmingly to green and blue zones. Homes there compounded; homes in red zones could not be financed or insured. The Black–white homeownership gap in L.A. County today is the shape of that ledger.
Property tax follows property value; school budgets followed both. Districts that overlap formerly D-graded areas still show lower per-pupil revenue and higher concentrations of students of color, decades after the grades were retired.
Formerly redlined neighborhoods across U.S. cities run hotter in summer than their A-graded counterparts — less canopy, more asphalt, fewer parks. In Los Angeles the gap maps closely onto Boyle Heights, South L.A. and Wilmington, though recent work finds present-day income inequality predicts heat burden more strongly than the grades alone.
Los Angeles appraisers noted oil wells when grading down. Of the 33 cities in a national well-siting study, Los Angeles had by far the most wells near HOLC-graded neighborhoods — some 6,618 — and most of them sat in D-graded ground, with Wilmington and Signal Hill among the most heavily drilled redlined districts.
1965 and 1992 both ignited in redlined corridors. The Christopher and McCone commissions described the same pattern a generation apart: heavier enforcement, thinner services, on the same blocks the sheets had colored red.
Disinvestment made land cheap; cheap land near downtown is now the target. Echo Park, Highland Park and Boyle Heights — C and D in 1939 — are where displacement pressure is sharpest today, and Inglewood is following.
When the covenants fell, the right-of-way took over. The Santa Monica Freeway was cut through Sugar Hill in the early 1960s, fifteen years after its homeowners beat the covenants in court. When the Century Freeway finally cut through in the years that followed, it displaced an estimated 9,000 families — about 21,000 people — and took some 3,900 single-family and 3,000 multi-family dwellings across Watts, Willowbrook, Lynwood and the rest of the corridor, as estimated in federal court when residents sued and won (Keith v. Volpe, 1972). Interchange land was cheap because the sheets had made it cheap.
The grades are gone; the valuation gap is not. Homes in majority-Black neighborhoods are valued below comparable homes in comparable white neighborhoods, and “whitewashing” cases in California — most famously Paul Austin and Tenisha Tate-Austin in Marin City, whose home appraised nearly half a million dollars higher once signs of a Black family were removed — show how much the appraiser’s read of a household can move the number. The federal PAVE task force (2022) exists because the modern appraisal file still carries the 1939 logic of “neighborhood.” Brookings (2018) · PAVE action plan
“Redlining laid the groundwork for decades of systemic inequality in Los Angeles.”
Sourced entries stand beside the record; memories stand as memories, and are marked so. Everything here was added by someone who lived it, or heard it from someone who did.
No entries yet. Yours can be the first.
Anyone can propose an entry; an editor checks the source before it stands beside the record. A place, a person, a record, a memory of a block. Give us a source where you have one; give us your name where you want it.
Questions, disagreements, what we got wrong. Keep it about the record and the city; we remove abuse.
No comments yet.